Selling In Central Florida? One Flooring Mistake Could Cost You $

One Flooring Mistake Could Cost You Thousands 💰

You’ve staged every room, polished every surface, and taken stunning listing photos. Your home looks flawless—until the first buyers walk in.

Then, you see it.

That slight hesitation. The subtle shift in their expression. The unspoken “Oh.”

It’s the floors.

Maybe it’s the outdated tile. Maybe it’s the worn-out wood that looked fine to you but screams “expensive repair” to them. Or maybe—worst of all—it’s the brand-new flooring you just installed, thinking it would add value.

And now? Buyers are mentally tallying renovation costs. They’re making excuses. They’re walking away.

As a Realtor in Orlando, Lake Mary, and throughout Central Florida, I see it happen all the time. The wrong flooring can derail your home’s appeal before buyers even make it past the entryway. That’s why, in my latest video, I’m revealing:

The biggest flooring mistakes that hurt home sales
The smartest flooring choices for resale
The #1 flooring decision that could cost you thousands

Why Flooring Matters More Than You Think

Buyers don’t just see flooring—they calculate it.

The moment they step in, they think:

🤔 How much time and money will it take to rip this out?

If the answer is too much, they’re out.

Replacing flooring is a hassle—especially in hot, humid areas like Orlando, Lake Mary, and Altamonte Springs. It’s expensive, messy, and time-consuming. Buyers don’t want to deal with it after closing—they want move-in ready. They’re already investing in a home, and the last thing they want is a major flooring project before they can even unpack.

I’ve seen homes sit on the market for months in places like Sanford and Winter Park simply because the floors were a deal breaker. And it’s not always because they were damaged—it’s because they were wrong for what buyers wanted.

Take one listing I worked on in Lake Mary. The home had been sitting unsold for months. Why? Terrible tile.

It wasn’t broken. It wasn’t dirty. But it was everywhere. Buyers took one look and walked back out the door.

Luckily, my sellers were flexible. We negotiated a flooring credit—but not every buyer is willing to play that game. Most just move on.

If your floors scream “expensive renovation,” you could be looking at lower offers, fewer showings, or worse—no offers at all.

Who Should You Actually Listen to About Flooring?

One of the biggest mistakes home sellers in Orlando, Altamonte Springs, and Sanford make? Asking the wrong person for flooring advice.

A lot of sellers ask their Realtor what type of flooring to install. And while I can tell you what buyers want, I’m not a decorator.

A real estate agent can tell you:

✔ What buyers love
✔ What adds value
✔ What flooring turns people away

But when it comes to style, color, or trends? That’s a decorator’s job.

Too often, homeowners choose flooring based on personal taste rather than buyer appeal. Then, when it’s time to sell, they realize… they made a huge mistake.

💡 The floors they loved? Buyers hate.

If you’re never moving and want your dream home? Do whatever you love.

But if selling is on your horizon—whether you’re in Lake Mary, Orlando, or anywhere in Central Florida—think about resale value first.

What Flooring Actually Adds Value?

If you want to maximize resale value, there’s one clear winner:

✅ Hardwood

✔ Timeless & classic – Fits nearly every home style
✔ Adds warmth – Buyers love the look and feel
✔ Durable – Can be refinished instead of replaced
✔ Increases perceived value – Homes with hardwood sell for more

Already have hardwood? DO NOT RIP IT OUT. Even if it’s scratched, refinishing it is always a better investment than replacing it with something new.

And yes—you can put hardwood in the kitchen. Unless you’re constantly flooding the floors, water damage isn’t an issue.

Now, for humid areas like Orlando and Sanford, engineered hardwood is a great alternative. It looks just like real wood, but it’s more durable and moisture-resistant. When my clients replaced that awful tile, we chose wide-plank engineered hardwood, and let me tell you—it was worth it.

✔ Looks high-end
✔ Extremely durable
✔ Holds value better than most options

And if you have pets? 🐶 Engineered hardwood is a lifesaver. It’s scratch-resistant and easier to maintain than traditional hardwood.

Want a more affordable option that still adds value? Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) is the way to go.

✔ Waterproof
✔ Scratch-resistant
✔ Looks like wood—so buyers love it

The Worst Flooring Choices for Resale

🚨 Some flooring choices don’t just fail to add value—they actively hurt your home’s resale potential.

❌ Carpet – Buyers don’t want someone else’s old carpet, even if it’s brand new
❌ Cheap laminate – Feels flimsy, noisy, and screams “builder-grade”
❌ Vinyl sheet flooring – Outdated, cheap-looking, and hard to repair

And the #1 flooring mistake that can destroy your home’s value?

👉 Covering up hardwood with vinyl plank. 👈

I see it all the time. Sellers think they’re modernizing their home, but they’re actually covering up one of their biggest selling points.

Buyers would rather see scratched-up hardwood than brand-new vinyl covering the real deal.

Thinking About Selling? Let’s Talk Flooring First

Flooring matters more than you think, and the wrong choice can cost you thousands.

If you’re in Orlando, Lake Mary, Sanford, or Altamonte Springs and thinking about updating your floors before selling, don’t make these mistakes.

👉 Watch my latest video for a full breakdown of what sells and what doesn’t.

And if you want expert guidance on selling your home in Central Florida, let’s chat. As a Realtor serving Orlando, Lake Mary, and beyond, I can help you make the best flooring choices—before buyers even step through the door.

📍 For Specific Areas, Click Below: